London London London black cab drivers lose Uber legal action

Mobile phone with Uber app in front of Big Ben Image copyright Reuters

Black cab drivers have lost a legal challenge which argued that Uber's London operating licence was granted by a biased judge.

The United Cabbies Group (UCG) said the decision to give Uber a 15-month permit in June was "tainted by actual or apparent bias".

The "probationary" licence was granted after Transport for London (TfL) refused to grant a five-year licence.

The High Court rejected the UCG's claims of bias on Tuesday.

In August Chief Magistrate Emma Arbuthnot, who granted the temporary licence, stepped down from hearing future cases involving Uber.

It followed a newspaper report about alleged financial connections between her husband, Lord Arbuthnot, and the ride-hailing app.

Image copyright PA
Image caption Taxi drivers have been campaigning against Uber, such as engaging in this "go slow" protest in 2014

At a hearing in London earlier this month, lawyers for UCG acknowledged Lady Arbuthnot was unaware of the links.

But they said she should have "checked for any potential conflicts of interest" before making her decision on Uber's licence.

They also argued the decision was not open to her because Uber did not meet the "fit and proper person" criteria necessary for holding a licence.

However, their case was dismissed by Lord Chief Justice Lord Burnett and Mr Justice Supperstone.

Lord Chief Justice Lord Burnett said in his ruling that the list of "tenuous connections unearthed" by UCG fell "well short of evidence that would begin to give a fair-minded observer even pause for thought".

London live reporting

Live BBC London Live: Latest updates

Full article BBC London Live: Latest updates

Top Stories

Indian strikes target militants in Pakistan

Pakistan scrambles fighter jets after Indian warplanes carry out strikes, in an escalation of tensions.

26 February 2019 May offers MPs Brexit delay vote 26 February 2019 Vandals decapitate 800-year-old 'crusader' 26 February 2019


Why cardinal's trial was kept secret

Inside small-town USA

Saudi Arabia takes charm offensive East

What next for 2019's Oscar winners?


Bill Granger: 'Godfather' of avocado toast

Trump and Kim in Hanoi: Your need-to-know guide

Jihadist takeover in Syria's last rebel enclave sparks alarm

Brexit: Talk of delay, but no conclusions

Soundtrack to a US-N Korea success story

Elsewhere on the BBC

Football phrases

15 sayings from around the world

Full article Football phrases Why you can trust BBC News

BBC News Services

Original Article


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here